Shutdown by Design: How State-Capacity Sabotage Stalls Industrial Renewal, Shreds Public Trust, and Hurts Families

A government that cannot govern, cannot build. That is the deeper story behind the looming shutdown. What looks like a budget standoff is, in practice, a deliberate effort to weaken the state’s ability to act.

Shutdowns were once rare. After the 1996 lapse, none occurred for nearly two decades. Yet, since 2013, they have grown more frequent and severe: a 16-day standoff in 2013 and back-to-back shutdowns in 2018, the second lasting a record 34 days. Each left real economic scars.

What makes this one different is the Trump administration’s embrace of shutdown politics as a governing strategy. It is not a breakdown of negotiations but a way to paint the government as incapable, demoralize its workers, and shift the burden of dysfunction onto the public—a continuation of chaotic DOGE tactics.

One of the first places this shows up is industrial policy, where ambitious public-private projects are being thrown into uncertainty.

Industrial Policy Interrupted

The state’s industrial turn—from the CHIPS Act to mining strategic minerals—depends on government agencies that can plan, partner, and deliver. A shutdown undercuts that foundation.

The Departments of Energy and Commerce, as well as the the Environmental Protection Agency, are central to launching new projects and enforcing environmental standards. Yet these and many other agencies have not even posted updated shutdown contingency plans as of this post, which are typically issued annually.

Without clear staffing, grants go unsigned, permits stall, and contracts are left in limbo. These delays may look technical, but to the communities waiting for a semiconductor fabrication plant to break ground, they will mean jobs lost and rising costs starting at midnight tonight.

It is worth remembering how different this is from moments of national ambition in the past. In the 1930s, the New Deal’s industrial expansion, from rural electrification to wartime production, required steady government capacity. Agencies did not shutter every few years. They operated continuously, building trust as they built infrastructure.

Yet, these industrial delays bleed into a broader problem: the deliberate weakening of state capacity and the legitimacy of government itself.

Shredding Capacity and Losing Legitimacy

Shutdowns have always meant furloughs. In past lapses, hundreds of thousands of federal employees have been sidelined, some sent home, others forced to work without pay.

This time, the threat is deeper. The White House directed agencies to prepare legally dubious reduction-in-force plans, permanent layoffs tied to whether jobs align with its own priorities. If carried out, the cuts would hollow agencies far beyond this shutdown.

The effects don’t stop with the federal workforce. Benefit checks may still go out, but a shutdown snarls the administrative machinery people depend on every day. Disability claim reviews for SSI and SSDI can pause. Call centers close. Small Business Administration loans freeze. During the 2019 shutdown, SBA was unable to process over $2 billion in loans.

For the people waiting—a disabled worker, a small business owner, a family navigating Social Security—these aren’t abstractions. They are weeks of anxiety, bills delayed, or opportunities foregone.

Over time, governance by crisis erodes democratic legitimacy itself. During the 2018–19 shutdown, consumer confidence fell sharply and the country’s credit rating came under threat. Each new standoff reinforces a sense that the government is unstable, which serves the agenda of those eager to discredit public power.

The economic toll, however, brings this fragility home. The shutdown is not just a fight over government operations. It is a direct hit to families, businesses, and communities.

Economic Consequences: The Real-Time Shockwaves

The most immediate pain of a shutdown comes from vanished paychecks. When federal workers miss paydays, retailers lose customers. Mortgage payments are delayed. For contractors, the blow is even harsher: Unlike federal employees, many may never see back pay. And this pain is not concentrated in DC. Roughly 80 percent of federal workers live outside of the District.

A shutdown ripples through regional economies. The National Flood Insurance Program depends on appropriations. If it lapses, as it has in past shutdowns, an estimated 1,300 home closings per day cannot proceed in flood-prone areas. Aviation and travel are slowed as Federal Aviation Administration training and hiring pipelines freeze. Each delay compounds into lost wages, lost growth, and lost confidence that harm the economy.

Layered on top is the looming health-care premium cliff. On November 1, Affordable Care Act health insurance plans will no longer include enhanced subsidies for those buying policies for next year. Families will begin receiving notices of steep hikes: premiums up an average 75 percent, with over 4 million at risk of losing coverage. Republicans have floated a “clean” continuing resolution through late November, which would blow past this deadline. The poor sleight of hand is glaring. By delaying budget negotiations while ignoring the cliff, they are setting up families to face both a government shutdown and unaffordable health insurance, all at once.

Capacity Is the Precondition for Progress

If every major policy must be fought through a hostage crisis, effective democracy itself is impossible. Shutdowns may start as political gambits, but they end as human harm: a paycheck missed in Virginia, a disability claim delayed in Ohio, a mortgage stalled in Louisiana, a health plan priced out in Arizona.

A functional government is not a luxury; it is the precondition for every other ambition. Industrial renewal will not happen if the lights are off at Energy and Commerce. Trust in democracy will not rebound if citizens are left on hold or furloughed without pay. The good life that progressives fight for cannot be realized if families face lost income and rising costs because of deliberate sabotage.

The GOP’s choice to run out the clock and punt real decisions into November would mean stalled factories, missed paychecks, closed home sales, and skyrocketing premiums. The alternative is simple: stop ruling by crisis, fortify the capacity to govern, and restore government as a force that can lead. Anything less sets us up to fail at the very moment we need bold public power the most.

---

Fireside Stacks is a weekly newsletter from Roosevelt Forward about progressive politics, policy, and economics. If you enjoyed this installment, consider sharing it with your friends.